The 2016 Chateauneuf du Pape l'Eperdu is 100% old-vine Grenache aged in 400-liter oak casks. A full-bodied, plush, warm wine that's loaded up with lumber, it offers scents of vanilla and cedar, while baking spices mark the smooth, supple finish. Unless you love new oak, give it a couple of years to see if the wood better integrates with what is undoubtedly some fine underlying fruit.